Skip to main content

Don's NY Pizza | Our Story

Our Story: A New Chapter at Don's NY Pizza

New York Tradition. Arizona Roots. Family-Owned Passion.

New York Tradition. Arizona Roots. Family-Owned Passion.

At Don's NY Pizza in Peoria, Arizona, we believe great pizza is about more than just dough, sauce, and cheese. It's about bringing people together, creating memories, and treating every customer like family. Don's has been part of the Peoria community for more than a decade, serving authentic New York-style pizza to families throughout the West Valley. In April 2026, our family proudly took ownership, bringing new energy, fresh ideas, and a renewed commitment to making Don's better than ever.

Bringing Back What Makes a Neighborhood Pizzeria Special

Our mission is simple: great food, exceptional service, and an experience that keeps you coming back. We've worked hard to build on Don's tradition of delicious, hand-tossed New York-style pizza while improving the experience for every guest who walks through our doors. We're not a big corporate chain. We're a locally owned family business that believes quality matters, customers deserve to feel appreciated, and every order should be made with pride.

More Than Just Great Pizza

While our authentic New York-style pizza remains the star of the show, we've expanded the experience with mouthwatering Philly cheesesteaks, crispy wings, juicy smash burgers, fresh calzones, and delicious desserts. We've even added a creative twist with our Apple Strudel Pizza Pie, bringing something sweet and unexpected to the table. And now, you can enjoy an ice-cold beer alongside your favorite pizza! Whether you're grabbing a quick New York slice, enjoying dinner with family, or watching the game with friends, there's something for everyone at Don's.

Our Family Serving Yours

As a family-owned business, we're personally invested in every customer experience. Our goal isn't just to make another sale. It's to earn your trust, your loyalty, and the opportunity to serve you again. We're proud of our team, grateful for our loyal customers, and excited to welcome new faces from Peoria, Glendale, and across the West Valley.

Rediscover Don's NY Pizza

If you've been coming to Don's for years, thank you for being part of our story. If it's been a while since your last visit, we'd love the opportunity to welcome you back. And if you've never tried us, there's never been a better time. Same New York-style tradition. New family ownership. A renewed passion for great pizza and great service. Come rediscover Don's NY Pizza, where every slice is served with pride. Don's NY Pizza 7539 W Peoria Ave, Peoria, AZ 85345 Family-Owned. Community-Focused. New York-Style Pizza Done Right.