Don's NY Pizza | Our Story

Where New York Meets the West Valley

Welcome to Don's NY Pizza in Peoria, AZ—your spot for classic New York–style pies with foldable, hand‑tossed crusts, zesty sauce, and melty mozzarella. Build your perfect pizza or choose from our house specialties, plus jumbo slices, wings, salads, and oven‑baked sides. Order online for quick pickup or local delivery, or stop in for friendly dine‑in service. From game night to weeknight dinners, Don's NY Pizza brings big‑city flavor to the West Valley.

A Mission to Get It Right

The West Valley had plenty of pizza options — just not the right kind. Don's was built to bring a genuine New York slice to Peoria, no shortcuts.

The Craft Behind the Crust

Hand-tossed dough, zesty sauce, mozzarella that bubbles and browns the way it should. Transplanted New Yorkers keep telling us we got it right.

A Full Italian-American Kitchen

Stuffed calzones, baked ziti, crispy wings, hot subs, fresh salads — there's a reason people keep coming back for more than just a pie.

The People Behind the Counter

Manager Antonio gets called out by name in reviews — that kind of personal touch isn't an accident. It's just how things run here.

Peoria's Neighborhood Pizza Spot

4.5 stars across 1,100+ reviews, a Phoenix Pizza Post nod as "in a category of its own." First-timers show up curious — regulars already know their order.